A lot of these urban legends have been around for a long time. I remember when there was a discussion on how long can an LP or a 45 or even a 78 will retain data. And this is analog technology. I still have 78's believe it or not (and a turntable to use em on :!: :shock: :wink: :lol: ) and the analog data is still very very useable and these were recorded back in the late 20's and early 30's.
Same applied to reel to reel tapes. Then 8-tracks then cassette tapes. This then translated to worries about Beta and VHS. These are all analog data storage systems.
Chad, you might be familiar with tyres as well - those pyrex/corning glass tape transport discs that were used in mainframes.. those also had data loss concerns.
As with all things man-made nothing is perfect and yes, these analog multilayer silver oxide embedded (?) data storage membranes can and will break down in time... but mostly through use or improper storage.
If these storage media are properly stored their life span can be measured in decades and not in years. I have reel-reel tapes that I recorded in 1975 that are still as crystal clear as the day I recorded them.. (I used to be a somewhat audiophile).
5-1/4" and 3-1/2" layered media disks (floppies) are also a concern. I have had good disks and bad disks right out of the box. These are manufacturing defects... not attrition from decay. I still use some of my 5-1/4" disks in older XT's and they still work. In fact, I still have 2 or 3 boxes of UNOPENED 5-1/4" floppies, but I do not have any of the earlier 10" jobbies...
I spent a decade in intercept where we used reel to reels, cassettes, tyres and other assorted storage media, and in our area where data loss is a huge concern, we never experienced much loss at all, and what loss was experienced usually was traced back to either complete loss of product (loss of aircraft etc..), operator neglect or error or just simply a manufacturer defect.
The same would apply to modern CD/R's and CD-RW's and DVD series of media. I again have CD's that I burned with drivers for old cards (I have dozens of those) burned on an old HP 8450 series 1x burner.. still as solid as the day they were burned (on a Win 95 machine) almost 10 years ago.
I think it is just primarily urban legend.
Chad, I am not a big fan of backup systems. In fact I despise them. I had thought once that MS did us a big favour by building in an auto backup utility in Win95... till I backed it up one day. Hard drive failure, necessitating a new drive. Went to restore the backup.. and it was useless as it needed the original drive signature.. so good data in, garbage out.. since that time, the only way I back up is to manually copy the files I need to another drive or to storage media like an R or RW disc.